1st Topic | Washington State |
National Standards Bundle | Theme #1 Culture: Demonstrate how holding different values and beliefs can contribute or pose obstacles to understanding between people and groups. Pg. 68
D2.His.14.3-5. Explain probable causes and effects of events and developments |
Bundle Defense | These two standards form an academically rich bundle because the National Standard theme is from the Culture theme, there is little overlap with the DCT history standard. The cultural theme covers the two groups beliefs and the misunderstandings and the history standard covers the actual causes and effects of this topic. |
Compelling Question | How were the Native Americans lives changed when settlers came and took over their land in the Pacific North West? |
Compelling Question Defense | This compelling question would be compelling for students because they would be drawn to what actually happened when the Native Americans land was taken. History textbooks can sometimes depict that it was peaceful, when it was really not. It is academically rich because it covers history and geography and prompts students to think critically about the cause and the effects of this historical event. |
Supporting questions that could be asked?
Answer that I think my students could achieve:
The lives of the Native Americans were changed forever when white settlers came and took over their land. They didn't have any rights to it anymore. They were forced to pack up and move to reservations. Their land provided them with food and were sacred places where their ancestors were buried. They were given some money, but not nearly enough in comparison to the situation. Native Americans used to inhabit a lot of the land in Washington and down into Oregon. This all happened because settlers didn't want any land to be empty, no matter if that meant disrupting the culture and lives of native groups.
Kaitlyn,
ReplyDeleteI can tell a lot of thought was put into the choosing of your theme and DCT. I agree with you that they are related, but not related too closely to where your students will be redundant in their answers. I really like your compelling question and your defense -- the question is honest and puts the situation in a light that it needs to be shown in. It wasn't all nice and pretty what happened, it was the opposite actually. I think it's important to teach these events as they actually happened to students will not be blindsided as they get older when they realize that the land was taken harshly from the Native Americans. Your supporting questions also supplement the compelling question very well, and I believe it will help keep your students on track when it comes to finding an answer for the overall question. Not only that but the supporting questions have definite answers and the compelling question can have multiple which is important. Good job!
Hi Tabatha,
DeleteThank you for the feedback! I agree that it is very important to put what happened to this group of people in the right light. I feel like a lot of what we learned about it was really just beating around the bush. We need to have our students starting to learn the real truth.
Hi Kaitlyn,
ReplyDeleteI’m glad you took this topic on! I think it’s important to talk about history that has been “covered up.” That’s actually one of the reasons I wanted to get into teaching! I think your supporting questions go very well with your compelling question. Would you want to bring up with your students how this part of history is typically taught? And explore why that is? If so, why? If not, why?
Hi Josie!
DeleteThank you for the feedback. To answer your question, I don't want to teach my students about this the same way I was taught. I want to teach them the real facts and the reality of what really happened. It wasn't peaceful and it wasn't fair. I'm still learning some of the facts myself to this day, and I believe that a lot of things went unsaid. Something that I would really like to do is not try to talk for this group of people, but rather have an expert come in and tell what happened honestly and truthfully.