I really had no idea what social studies inquiry was before this module. In the last blog post where I tried to define it on my own, I was way off the mark. Social Studies Inquiries are linked the the big, key ideas of Social Studies. They are intended to provide examples of content and get students to think in an inquiry-based way. There are compelling and supporting questions that students will answer with the support of resources and evidence. I learned that the compelling question isn't just meant to be a really hard question that your students have to answer without any help. We pose a complicated question and then provide our students with the resources and evidence to answer the question. I found this video that helped my understanding further:
A compelling question is important because it forces students to use some critical thinking skills. It is challenging academically as well as relevant to the students. A compelling question would be really difficult to answer before exploring the supporting questions and resources that go along with them. These supporting questions are really setting the framework of knowledge to be able to thoughtfully answer the compelling question. When creating my own compelling question from the "time to process" assignment, I also thought about whether the question I was posing would have any relevant supporting questions. The example I will use here is from the Oregon Trail category. The compelling question I came up with was "If people had known the difficulties of traveling along the Oregon Trail, would they have still made the trip?" We were taught in school that traveling the Oregon Trail came with a lot of difficulties. Sickness (especially cholera), lack of resources, and especially weather conditions. Some supporting questions for this larger question could be "What were the conditions these people were already living in?" "What did this new land have to offer?" Both answers to these questions would outweigh some of the difficulties that could happen. Just like our discussion in class about crossing the Delaware, the risk of traveling the Oregon Trail was worth what was waiting for them on the other side.
The question that I keep going back to in my mind is how do you know if your supporting questions relate to the overall compelling question?
One potential answer to this would be to make the compelling question broad enough to have some supporting questions, but at the same time not too broad or the value of the question is taken away.
I am right there with you on not having any prior knowledge about social studies inquiry before this -- I attempted to piece everyone's definitions together to make sense of it but that didn't necessarily work for me either once I found out what it actually means. The video you posted in your blog also furthered my understand as well as this last weeks module, so thank you for sharing that! Also -- you posed an interesting question, but I also think the answer you provided was good as well! If you have a compelling question, some supporting questions might also come from the thinking you do in your own brain and what questions arise while you, as the teacher, are coming up with the compelling question.
Hi Tabatha, Thank you for the feedback! I'm glad you found the video helpful too! I was really struggling to get it to embed correctly, so I almost gave up on it, but good thing I didn't. Trying to think about how I would answer the compelling question did help me to think of a few supporting ones.
I am in the same boat as you, as I had no idea what social studies inquiry was, and how it can be a great model for teaching. I like the question you posed, about supporting questions relating to the overall compelling question- I think this a very important question to have during the inquiry process as it can help in deciding if the supporting question contributes to forming the answer to the compelling question. I think your answer to the question is spot on, and how important it is that the compelling question is both broad enough to allow for supporting questions, but not to broad that the question loses the inquiry purpose. What type of question do you think would be too broad? Great post!
Hi Sarah, One type of question that I think would be too broad would be more of an hypothetical. A question that wouldn't necessarily have an answer. At first in the class activity, I thought his compelling question was too hard to answer, but he had some really good supporting questions that made coming up with a reasonable answer much easier. I think a good rule to follow would be if you can't think of any supporting questions that would help them come to the answer, you should probably think of a new compelling question.
Hey Kaitlyn, I had no idea how in-depth that inquiry could really be. It was fascinating learning about how it works. I really liked how you stated that a compelling question can really make students think and break down their pre-existing notions. So often we think that we have to teach the same way as we were taught and not put any new things into it. However this week showed that there is so much more that we can do to teach our students the knowledge that they need and make it fun and engaging. I feel like if we keep the question broad it will bring up the students to want to ask questions and get more engaged in what we are learning. If we go to narrow it does not allow students to think much about what we are teaching.
My fourth and fifth grade years, I was lucky enough to have a teacher who was very passionate about social studies, especially the history aspect. When I was in fourth grade we each dressed up as a member of Lewis and Clark's "team," for a lack of better word, and went on a field trip to Fort Clatsop. When learning about the Civil War, we each got to choose a "side" and at the end of the unit we played a game of dodgeball to see which side would win. We also had a journal where we wrote from the perspective of a soldier. Another activity we did surrounded the Oregon Trail. We created a persona of someone traveling along the Oregon Trail and had a journal where we told the story of our journey. I remember how much I enjoyed these activities and I actually still have that Oregon Trail journal, which I included some pictures of. . Social Studies can be seen as a boring topic to some students, speaking more specifically about the history or civics aspects. I remem...
1 st Topic Washington State National Standards Bundle Theme #1 Culture: Demonstrate how holding different values and beliefs can contribute or pose obstacles to understanding between people and groups. Pg. 68 D2.His.14.3-5 . Explain probable causes and effects of events and developments Bundle Defense These two standards form an academically rich bundle because the National Standard theme is from the Culture theme, there is little overlap with the DCT history standard. The cultural theme covers the two groups beliefs and the misunderstandings and the history standard covers the actual causes and effects of this topic. Compelling Question How were the Native Americans lives changed when settlers came and took over their land in the Pacific North West? Compelling Question Defense This compelling question would be compelling for students because they would be drawn to what actually happened when the Native Americans land was taken. History textbooks ...
I am right there with you on not having any prior knowledge about social studies inquiry before this -- I attempted to piece everyone's definitions together to make sense of it but that didn't necessarily work for me either once I found out what it actually means. The video you posted in your blog also furthered my understand as well as this last weeks module, so thank you for sharing that! Also -- you posed an interesting question, but I also think the answer you provided was good as well! If you have a compelling question, some supporting questions might also come from the thinking you do in your own brain and what questions arise while you, as the teacher, are coming up with the compelling question.
ReplyDeleteHi Tabatha,
DeleteThank you for the feedback! I'm glad you found the video helpful too! I was really struggling to get it to embed correctly, so I almost gave up on it, but good thing I didn't. Trying to think about how I would answer the compelling question did help me to think of a few supporting ones.
Hi Kaitlyn!
ReplyDeleteI am in the same boat as you, as I had no idea what social studies inquiry was, and how it can be a great model for teaching. I like the question you posed, about supporting questions relating to the overall compelling question- I think this a very important question to have during the inquiry process as it can help in deciding if the supporting question contributes to forming the answer to the compelling question. I think your answer to the question is spot on, and how important it is that the compelling question is both broad enough to allow for supporting questions, but not to broad that the question loses the inquiry purpose. What type of question do you think would be too broad? Great post!
Hi Sarah,
DeleteOne type of question that I think would be too broad would be more of an hypothetical. A question that wouldn't necessarily have an answer. At first in the class activity, I thought his compelling question was too hard to answer, but he had some really good supporting questions that made coming up with a reasonable answer much easier. I think a good rule to follow would be if you can't think of any supporting questions that would help them come to the answer, you should probably think of a new compelling question.
Hey Kaitlyn,
ReplyDeleteI had no idea how in-depth that inquiry could really be. It was fascinating learning about how it works. I really liked how you stated that a compelling question can really make students think and break down their pre-existing notions. So often we think that we have to teach the same way as we were taught and not put any new things into it. However this week showed that there is so much more that we can do to teach our students the knowledge that they need and make it fun and engaging. I feel like if we keep the question broad it will bring up the students to want to ask questions and get more engaged in what we are learning. If we go to narrow it does not allow students to think much about what we are teaching.